10 Best Sandwich Toaster Reviews - The Top Rated Models In 2019

Last Updated on

Imagine mouth-watering waffles for breakfast, a deliciously oozy cheese and ham toastie for lunch, and perfectly grilled chicken for dinner. Now think about a sandwich toaster that can make all this come true.

Our best sandwich toaster review shares only the finest appliances that will fuel your creativity and feed those hungry mouths with yummy treats.

Best Sandwich Toasters Reviews

Sandwich Toasters Comparison Chart

Top 10 Best Sandwich Toasters In 2019 Reviewed

The best sandwich toaster is the Sandwich/Panini Press and Toastie Maker By Breville. We gave it a 5/5 star rating.

The Breville VST026 Sandwich Press eases for the best Panini press. It is large enough and the hinged lid makes it suitable for a large sized sandwich. Among the sandwiches you can prepare with the Breville VST026 Sandwich Press include ciabatta, pitta, tortillas, focaccia and other breakfast snacks. 

You do not have to worry about space since the Breville VST026 Sandwich Press is compact enough to fit on an economically spaced kitchen worktop. If you enjoy your sandwiches golden brown with perfect edges, then the Breville VST026 Sandwich Press will do more than enhance your appetite for sandwiches.

The Breville VST026 Sandwich Press is a large sandwich press whose size makes it suitable for family meals. It has deep plates that can accommodate up to four sandwiches in one go.

Sandwich/Panini Press and Toastie Maker By Breville

Also, the hinged lid means that you can prepare sandwiches of varying thicknesses without worrying about them fitting into the plates. What is more, the plates are removable, non-stick and can be cleaned in a dishwasher. Apart from helping you with sandwich preparations, the Breville VST026 Sandwich Press can also help you to warm tortillas and naan bread. You can also cook crumpets, toast teacakes, and bagels.

It comes with two light indicators to notify you when the machine is switched on and when it is ready to cook. The ready-to-cook indicator lets you know when the hot plates have heated up enough to cook your sandwich meal. If you like, you can clean it immediately after cooking by wiping the plates with a damp cloth. It is advisable to do this before storing the Breville VST026 Sandwich Press away. This is because it will prevent dirt from accumulating on the plates thus making it hard to clean.

READ NEXT: The best electric can opener you can buy

  • It is perfect for preparing sandwiches for the family since it can prepare up to four sandwiches at a time
  • It is easy to clean since the plates are non-stick
  • Does not use up a lot of storage space since you can lock the lid and store the machine in an upward position
  • Can be a bit noisy when in operation

Second place goes to the Sandwich/Panini Press By Breville. We gave it a 5/5 star rating.

Breville is known for manufacturing the best kitchen equipment that helps to enhance the cook’s creativity and the Breville VST025 Sandwich Press is not an exception.

It is a stainless steel sandwich maker with flat non-stick coated aluminum plates that are large enough to make three sandwiches at once. 

The Breville VST025 Sandwich Press comes with a hinged lid which makes it easy to accommodate bread slices of different sizes and thicknesses. You should feel free to engage in other activities while preparing your sandwich since it comes with a power-on and ready-to-cook light indicator that is visible and quite helpful.

Sandwich/Panini Press By Breville

This sandwich maker has a 100W power rating which makes it one of the powerful toasters on the market that produces hot, and delicious Panini. The locking system of the hinged lid makes the Breville VST025 Sandwich Press a convenient machine to use for making sandwiches of all sorts of sizes. Some of the interesting features of the Breville VST025 Sandwich Press include the cool touch handle which means you are not susceptible to burns when handling your sandwich and Panini. It is also worth noting that the non-stick aluminum coating makes it very easy to clean the Breville VST025 Sandwich Press. 

The Breville VST025 Sandwich Press gives you a wide range of cooking options with each one taking only a fraction of the time you’d spend if you were using a standard Panini press. All you need to do is prepare your ingredients and let the Breville VST025 Sandwich Press do the rest. The easy-to-use features packed in the Breville VST025 Sandwich Press makes it a sandwich maker that is dedicated to promoting innovation by saving you the time without sacrificing the quality of café-style sandwiches.

  • It is easy to use
  • Easy to clean up after use
  • Requires little storage space
  • According to several Panini maker reviews, the Breville VST025 Sandwich Press is not suitable for large portions

Third place goes to the Sandwich Maker By Cuisinart. We gave it a 4.5/5 star rating.

Which Toaster Is Best? Well the Cuisinart GRSM1U Sandwich Maker is the perfect machine for the deepest, tastiest toasted sandwiches. Its design features extra-large pockets that allow you to use Ciabatta, Foccacia, or thick slices of hand-cut bread stuffed with anything that you prefer.

The Cuisinart GRSM1U Sandwich Maker is considered the best toastie maker overall in the market because other than making quick and easy meals with ease, it is also quite efficient and gives you great value for your money. This sandwich maker is perfect for fruit pastries, omelets, French toasts and quesadillas among other meals.

Sandwich Maker By Cuisinart

It has fast heat up capabilities with a ready indicator light to notify you when your sandwich is ready. Its housing is made from a robust and durable commercial grade brushed stainless steel. It also has a variable temperature control to allow you to achieve that perfect browning without burning your sandwich meal. The variable temperature control also means that you can do other things while waiting for your sandwich to be ready. It has removable non-stick plates that are large enough to provide sufficiently for accommodating even the thickest bread slices. The design of the Cuisinart GRSM1U Sandwich Maker makes it perfect for experimenting a wide range of sandwich dishes with each one giving you a perfectly sealed edge. 

An interesting aspect of the Cuisinart GRSM1U Sandwich Maker is that you can open the lid even while still preparing your sandwich. This means that you have more control and you can check the progress of your sandwich anytime. The light indicator illuminates green when the machine reaches the maximum temperature. It is worth noting that the Cuisinart GRSM1U Sandwich Maker is also quite easy to clean since the plates are removable, non-stick and are dishwasher safe.

READ NEXT: Top rated electric knife sharpener reviews

  • It is easy to clean because the removable plates are non-stick and dishwasher safe
  • Has variable temperature control to give you a perfectly browned sandwich
  • It is perfect for other recipes including omelets and fruit pastries among others
  • Comes with a lengthy manufacturer’s warranty of 5 years
  • The plates are large enough to accommodate even the thickest slices
  • A couple of sandwich toaster reviews pointed out that the Cuisinart GRSM1U Sandwich Maker breaks down after a short period of usage

Fourth place goes to the Sandwich Press By Breville. We gave it a 4.5/5 star rating.

The Breville VST049 Café-style Sandwich Press is a brushed stainless steel sandwich maker that specializes in the making of café-style sandwiches. It is designed with creativity in mind allowing you to prepare the best toasties such as Panini, Focaccia, and Ciabatta.

What is more exciting is the fact that this machine comes with interesting features including a cord storage, cool touch handle and an included booklet that is equipped with instructions on how to set it up and prepare various sandwiches. Just make sure you follow all the instructions appropriately and you will get the best results from the Breville VST049 Café-style Sandwich Press.

Sandwich Press By Breville

It comes in a compact design that makes it easy to store away after use. For instance, the code storage makes sure that you can save storage space. Also, those with a limited worktop space do not have to worry because the Breville VST049 Café-style Sandwich Press comes with a lock that allows you to have it standing in an upright position which utilizes less space. This machine features a floating hinged lid. This means that the top plate can move easily so as to accommodate sandwiches of varying sizes and thicknesses. The position of the cord storage makes it convenient as it does not mess up the setup of your kitchen worktop or storage cabinet. 

If you are one of those people who find post use cleanup to be dreadful, you have nothing to worry about since the Breville VST049 Café-style Sandwich Press comes with non-stick plates that are flat. This means that toasting plain bread without fillings has been made easy. On top of that, the need to apply oil or butter to the plates prior to cooking has been eliminated by the fact that the plates are non-stick. The only thing you need to be keen on when using the Breville VST049 Café-style Sandwich Press is the instruction manual. Make sure you follow the instructions to the letter. Otherwise, you run the risk of messing up the entire sandwich making process.

  • It is easy to use provided that you follow the instructions
  • Does not require a lot of effort to clean up the Breville VST049 Café-style Sandwich Press since it has non-stick plates
  • The floating hinged lid makes it possible for you to prepare sandwiches of different sizes and thicknesses
  • You won’t require a lot of space to store the Breville VST049 Café-style Sandwich Press after use
  • Some of the sandwich toasters reviews pointed out that the heat is not evenly distributed on the plates
  • It is also too small and can only handle one or two sandwiches at a time
  • The Breville VST049 Café-style Sandwich Press lacks an ON/OFF switch
  • It may slip off the worktop while you are preparing your sandwich because it is not heavy

Fifth place goes to the Portion Family Health Grill By George Foreman. We gave it a 4.5/5 star rating.

The George Foreman 18471 is a sizable sandwich maker that is capable of accommodating up to 4 meal portions. The exciting thing about this machine is that there is a wide range of meals that you can prepare. Some of them include meat, chicken, fish, and vegetables.

These are in addition to conventional toasties and Panini. It is designed to offer a perfect combination of convenience and efficiency. Both the top and bottom plates take part in cooking the food thus reducing the total preparation time. If you are wondering how the George Foreman sandwich maker works, it channels fat and grease from the food during the cooking process so that your final meal is healthy, tasty and appealing to the eye.

Portion Family Health Grill By George Foreman

When it comes to the ease of use, the George Foreman sandwich maker is both easy and safe. It comes with a light indicator to show when the machine is turned on and when it has reached the optimum temperature. The George Foreman 18471 is an efficient means of preparing your meals because it takes approximately half the time to grill your food compared to an oven or a microwave. A combination of the top and bottom plates at the same time means that you are going to reduce the duration of cooking which goes a long way in saving time and energy. 

The George Foreman 18471 grill comes in black and weighs only 2.07Kg. You do not have to worry about safety when using this machine because it does not easily slip off the worktop thanks to the non-slip feet. Despite having a power rating of only 160W, the George Foreman 18471 grill has a class A energy efficiency rating. It is worth noting that the approximated runtime of this grill is one minute, which is almost a quarter of the time it takes for most of the grills to prepare food.

  • It is large enough for a large meal that can satisfy an entire family
  • It is easy to use
  • Post use cleanup is simple and straightforward
  • Comes with a 2 year’s manufacturer’s warranty
  • Despite being advertised a 4-portion grill, it does not cook enough food for more than two people
  • Some of the sandwich makers reviews complained that this grill broke down after a few days

Sixth place goes to the Deep Fill Sandwich Maker By Tower. We gave it a 4.5/5 star rating.

If you are looking for a sandwich maker and you are on a tight budget, the Cerastone T27013 is probably the best choice you can get. It is a stylishly designed toaster that is known to create some of the best deep filled toasted sandwiches.

The plates are designed with a ceramic coating that is non-stick to allow you to have an easy time cleaning up after use. This feature also helps to eliminate the need to use oil or butter, which means you can obtain healthy sandwiches. To make it even more convenient, the Cerastone T27013 has nicely risen ridges that serve to cut and seal the sandwiches to prevent the ingredients from spilling out.

The Cerastone T27013 is also one of the safest sandwich makers to use as it comes with a cool-touch housing and handles so that you don’t get burnt when using it. Also, the feet are non-slip to enhance its stability when in use.

Deep Fill Sandwich Maker By Tower

It can comfortably make two sandwich portions and the uniquely designed ridges make the final sandwich, even more, appealing with the top curving and the sealed edges. According to most toasted sandwich maker reviews, the Cerastone T27013 is a great best-priced sandwich maker that you can depend on for a long time. 

When it comes to ease of use and convenience, the Cerastone T27013 ranks high on the list. It comes with two indicator lights for showing when the machine is powered on and when it is ready to cook your sandwich. Also, the lid is hinged and has a locking clip so that you can an evenly browned sandwich. The coating in the plates of this sandwich maker comprises of strong stone particles (Cerastone technology) to facilitate the even distribution of heat. It is the same technology that serves to eliminate the need for oil and butter in the preparation of sandwiches.

  • The Cerastone T27013 is reasonably priced yet it delivers an impressive performance
  • It is easy to use and does not pose safety risks
  • It is easy to clean since it features a non-stick coating
  • You can prepare healthy sandwiches since it does not require the use of oil or butter
  • It is difficult to find the bread slices that fit
  • Does not allow for a generous amount of fillings unless you use a crustless bread slice

Seventh place goes to the Snack Maker By Salter. We gave it a 4/5 star rating.

The Salter EK2143 snack maker is a perfect machine that serves three major functions facilitated by the interchangeable top and bottom plates. These include one top and bottom waffle plate, a top and bottom Panini plate and a top and bottom toasted sandwich grill plate. Each of these plates is large and deep enough to accommodate slices of different sizes. They are also non-stick to make it easy to clean and prevent your sandwich from crumbling and tearing. If you enjoy making your sandwiches, waffles, and Panini from the comfort of your home, then you are definitely going to love the Salter EK2143.

When it comes to safety, you are guaranteed of a safe operation when working with the Salter EK2143 because it comes with a power and ready-to-cook light indicators. Also, the plates are easy to remove although you need to follow the instructions in the user manual.

Snack Maker By Salter

Other than being removable and extremely easy to use, the plates of the Salter EK2143 are also extra-large making them ideal for large family sandwiches and deep-filled snacks. You are going to enjoy thicker treats that are also tastier than most of the other sandwich dishes. It has a power rating of 900 watts meaning that you can have your sandwiches, snacks, and waffles ready in a matter of minutes. 

With this machine, you are guaranteed of a waffle that is thicker than most of the stand waffles. In addition, you will also get a longer Panini that is up to 25cm and 60% larger toasties. Among the recipes that you can prepare with this machine include the hash brown waffles, quesadilla waffles, pesto, sundried tomato toasties, mozzarella, strawberry, banana and hazelnut chocolate toasties. The Salter EK2143 is one of the most compact snack makers on the market as it weighs only 3.37Kg and measures 11cm by 25cm by 29cm.

  • It is a multifunctional machine that allows you to achieve a wide range of snack making tasks
  • It has a locking latch, cool-touch handle which makes it easy and safe to use
  • The plates are non-stick making it easy to clean
  • The Salter EK2143 is powerful enough to facilitate quick sandwich preparation
  • The plate mounds can be too big for a decent toasted sandwich
  • The 900W is not high enough to make other desserts

Eighth place goes to the Dura Ceramic Sandwich Press By Breville. We gave it a 4/5 star rating.

The Breville VST071 Dura Ceramic Sandwich Press is a light grey sandwich maker that is perfect for Panini, wraps and crumpets and ciabatta. It features those aspects of design that make it particularly suitable for warming pittas, naan bread and croissants. Such features include a uniquely finished body that consists of a natural Dura Ceramic coating that makes the Breville VST071 Dura Ceramic Sandwich Press an advanced sandwich maker compared to others on the market that have a standard non-stick coating.

The Breville VST071 Dura Ceramic Sandwich Press has a locking lid that features a hinge to allow you to use it for sandwiches with different sizes.

Dura Ceramic Sandwich Press By Breville

The size and thickness of the slice is no longer an issue with this sandwich maker. What is more, you can easily store it away in an upright position once you are done using it. This is because it has a lockable plate. The other interesting and useful feature is the variable temperature control setting that lets you change the temperature between low medium and high settings. As a result, you do not have to worry about your sandwich getting burnt in the process of cooking. 

The Dura Ceramic coating is the outstanding feature of the Breville VST071 Dura Ceramic Sandwich Press and it literally gives you the power to determine how your sandwich turns out. For starters, you will achieve fast cooking as it increases the cooking speed by 20%. Secondly, the dura ceramic coating is resistant to scratch, hence making it quite durable over a long period. As a matter of fact, the Breville VST071 Dura Ceramic Sandwich Press is said to be four times more durable compared to conventional non-stick coatings. This means that you are going to enjoy hassle-free cleaning, crumb-free sandwiches that are free of any kinds of flakes.

  • It is easy to use and clean
  • Durable and scratch resistant
  • Allows you to achieve fast cooking
  • It is easy to store after use
  • Can be noisy when turned on
  • According to several sandwich maker reviews, the Breville VST071 Dura Ceramic Sandwich Press is difficult to use

Ninth place goes to the Deep Fill Sandwich Toaster Press By Salter. We gave it a 4/5 star rating.

The EK2017S is Salter’s deepest fill sandwich toaster that comes with extra large non-stick plates that can accommodate two toasties at once. With the powerful 900W heating element, you can have your toasties ready in approximately 4 minutes, which is a relatively fast rate compared to most toasters in its category.

The EK2017S is extremely easy and safe to use. For starters, the handle is cool to the touch, which means you are at liberty to check the progress of your sandwich without running the risk of getting burnt. It also has a simple locking latch as well as a power on and ready indicator light.

Since the plates are non-stick, you are guaranteed of perfectly cooked sandwiches that are free of flakes and crumbs.

Deep Fill Sandwich Toaster Press By Salter

Also, post-use cleanup is much easier since the plates are coated with a non-stick coating. You do not have to scrub this sandwich maker when cleaning it. As a matter of fact, you only need to wipe it with a damp cloth and you will be good to go. It goes without saying that since the sandwich does not stick to the plates, you are able to obtain perfectly browned toasties that taste and look great. 

One of the best things that you are probably going to love about this toaster is the fact that it makes toasts that are more than 50% bigger than ordinary sandwiches. This is because of the extra deep fill plates that the EK2017S comes with and the bread slices don’t have to be cut to fit in the toaster. You are not going to be dealing with cheese overflows either. So, you can have the peace of mind of knowing that the preparation process will not be messy in any way. Some of the recipes that you can try with the EK2017S include the croquet monsieur; the tuna cheese melt, the French onion and tomato, and the strawberry, banana, and chocolate.

  • It is a deep fill sandwich maker which means it offers great room for large sandwiches
  • The locking catch, the cool-touch handle, and the non-slip feet make the EK2017S one of the safest sandwich makers to use
  • The non-stick plates mean that you can easily clean it by wiping with a damp cloth after use
  • It is powerful to facilitate fast cooking
  • It is difficult to find the right size of bread for this sandwich maker
  • The locking catch is plastic and flimsy

Tenth place goes to the Sandwich Toaster By Vonshef. We gave it a 4/5 star rating.

Of all the above electric toaster reviews, there are very few electric sandwich makers on the market that can double as a waffle maker and a grill. Luckily, VonShef has got your back. You no longer have to go through a lot of trouble in trying to find an electric sandwich maker that is reasonably priced yet it performs multiple functions. The VonShef 3-in-1 sandwich maker can do a lot of things other than making sandwiches. For instance, you can use it as a Panini press, a waffle maker or a grill. The plates are removable and they are easy to clean since they have a non-stick coating.

If you want to use it as a waffle maker, all you need to do is replace the current plate with a waffle plate and you are good to go. The same applies to grilling and making sandwich toasts. The size of this sandwich maker is 23.4cm by 23.3cm by 9.3cm and it has a power rating of 700W. When it comes to the ease of use, this sandwich maker is one of the most user-friendly you can have on the market. It comes with a power on and ready light indicator. This way, you are able to know when the machine has reached the optimum temperature for cooking your sandwich.

Sandwich Toaster By Vonshef

The black design and the contemporary brushed stainless steel makes the VonShef 3-in-1 sandwich maker one of the stylish machines you can have for your kitchen. In addition, it has a carry handle that is conveniently positioned to make it easy to carry from one point to another. When placed on a kitchen worktop, this sandwich maker is stable as it has non-slip feet. You can be sure to receive the best service from this machine considering that it comes with a warranty of 2 years from the manufacturers.

  • It is affordable
  • This sandwich maker can perform multiple functions
  • As far as several sandwich maker reviews are concerned, it is the best sandwich toaster with removable plates
  • It is worth noting that cleaning this sandwich maker can be quite difficult if anything spills and seeps on the surface
  • The flimsy nature of this sandwich maker can make you doubt if it can last so long

A Guide To Sandwich Toasters

Think of all the recipes you would treat your family to if you had the right sandwich toaster as part of your kitchen appliances. Not forgetting that the sandwich would be made with fresh bread from your bread maker. It would be sliced to perfection with an electric carving knife or a blade made sharp with an electric knife sharpener.

True, a toaster will get you the crispy bread you need and the bagel slicer will get you the perfectly made bagel sandwich. But there is a wide range of ingredients you can add from your small table top freezer to a sandwich toaster. For instance, adding leftover chicken can make it more delicious. Here is how you can pick the right sandwich toaster.

The Benefits Of Owning A Sandwich Maker

Kitchens are receiving new appliances at an unprecedented rate these days. One of the most recent of these appliances is the sandwich maker. It is a small machine that uses electric power to make toasted sandwiches. Unlike traditionally prepared toasties, sandwiches made with a sandwich maker are better in several ways. For instance, they provide you with great health benefits. On the other hand, sandwich makers are fairly cheaper than grills and microwave ovens. If you have a small kitchen space and you want a way to maximize its use, the sandwich maker has got your back. It has design features that allow you to economize on storage space. Some of these features include the cord storage, and a lockable lid that allows you to store it in an upright position.

The other benefit of a sandwich maker is the fact that you can use it to make healthy sandwiches. Most of the sandwich makers have a design feature that eliminates the need to use butter or oil. The presence of a scratch resistant coating on the plates is a feature that contributes to the assertion that the sandwich maker benefits the user by allowing them to make healthy foods.

Benefits Of Owning A Sandwich Maker

A sandwich maker is a machine that can be used for multiple functions. For instance, the 3-in-1 sandwich maker is equipped with an indoor grill and a waffle maker. Therefore, make sure you grab yourself one today and enjoy these benefits.

Safety Precautions

Just like any other piece of equipment, sandwich maker ought to be handled with great care and precautions in order to get the best out of it. Most of the people that have used the sandwich maker before will tell you that it is not all rosy and that there is a bit of a learning curve involved. The most important thing to note is that using an electric device requires a great deal of care and precaution and the sandwich maker is not an exception. Here are some of the safety precautions that everyone needs to observe. 

Always follow the guidelines of the instructions manual that came with the sandwich maker. There are instructions that are standard across all sandwich making devices and there are those which are specific to a particular product. To be on the safe side, always read and follow the instructions of the sandwich making a brand that you are having. Avoid making assumptions. Since the use of a sandwich maker entails the connection to an electric outlet, you should always find out of the voltage ratings of the outlet are capable of powering the sandwich maker.

Factors To Consider

There are three main factors that one needs to put into consideration when buying a sandwich maker. The first one is the condition of the cooking plates.

The cooking plates’ condition refers to the material from which they are mad and their quality. The best sandwich maker plates are those that are made from a durable material and are durable. Most of the people that have used a sandwich maker before recommending the one that comes with non-stick plates.

The second factor of consideration is the size of the sandwich maker. This will be determined by the size of your kitchen and the feeding needs of your family. If you are a large family that enjoys sandwiches every breakfast, then a small sandwich maker would not be convenient for you. 

The other factor of consideration in the purchase of a sandwich maker is the ease of use. Naturally, you are going to prefer a machine that gives you an easy time interacting with it.

Appliances that are hard to use leave a bad impression and are likely to under perform. Therefore, when buying a sandwich maker, it is advisable to choose the one that does not give you a hard time when using it.

Sandwich Toasters FAQs

Q: Which is the right sandwich maker for me?

A: The right sandwich maker for you depends on several factors including your budget, the size of your family and the kitchen space that you have.

Q: Are the plates removable and dishwasher safe?

A: Manufacturing companies have their own ways of producing sandwich makers. While some produce sandwich makers with removable and dishwasher safe plates, others do the exact opposite.

Q: What size of the loaf should I use on the sandwich maker?

A: The size of the loaf will depend on the size of the plates. 

Additional Reading You May Enjoy

About the Author Catherine Wheeler

Hey, I'm Cath :) Iv'e got two beautiful young girls who mean the world to me. I used to be a head chef over at my local restaurant but I gave that up to look after my girls. I decided to put my culinary experience to use here by bringing that wealth of kitchen related knowledge and sharing it with you guys.

follow me on: